FIVE of the world’s biggest food manufacturers are to start a huge
advertising campaign in an effort to defeat government proposals for
“traffic light” labelling of food.
Kellogg’s, Danone, Kraft, Nestlé and Pepsico plan to promote
their own rival labelling scheme instead.
The move is certain to put the industry on a collision course with the
government and the Food Standards Agency.
Food manufacturers believe that they are being made scapegoats for
Britain’s obesity epidemic and are frustrated by what they see as a
lack of understanding in government.
In July, Tony Blair warned the industry against rejecting the
traffic-light system advocated by the Food Standards Agency and food
campaigners.
“We are encouraging the industry to adopt the Food Standards
Agency’s clear system for labelling. We are prepared to act if the
voluntary system does not work,” the prime minister warned.
But the big five manufacturers have drawn up plans for an
unprecedented joint campaign that will promote the industry’s rival
scheme, which tells consumers what percentage of their “guideline
daily allowance” (GDA) of sugar, fat and salt is contained in a
product.
The five produce many foods and drinks that children like, such as
breakfast cereal, yoghurt and Pepsi. Unilever, which makes Flora
margarine and Hellmann’s mayonnaise, and soup firm Campbell’s are
also believed to be backing the idea.
The television and press campaign is being co-ordinated by the Food
and Drink Federation, although the five manufacturers will provide
most of the funding. Details are still being finalised, but industry
sources believe it could be launched within weeks.
Traffic-light labels appear to have a big affect on consumer
behaviour. The Sunday Times revealed in April that J Sainsbury —
which has introduced the traffic-light scheme on some of its own-label
products — had suffered a 40% fall in sales of chicken madras since
the introduction of labelling. Other ready meals also had sharp
declines.
But the food manufacturers claim that their GDA scheme is more
popular with customers. “We think we have a better alternative that
helps consumers to make sensible choices about what they eat,” said
Julian Hunt, director of communications at the Food and Drink
Federation.
However, the Food Standards Agency and food campaigners argue that
GDA labelling is too confusing for consumers.
Traffic-light labelling — which gives red, amber or green traffic
lights for levels of sugar, fat and salt content — is much better
understood and effective, said the agency.
Plans for the GDA campaign could also cause a row within the food
industry. A number of smaller food manufacturers and Food and Drink
Federation members are understood to have worries about the campaign,
which they fear could antagonise the government.
Many food manufacturers — alongside Tesco — have backed GDA
labelling. But Sainsbury, Waitrose, Asda and the Co-operative Group
have decided to support the traffic-light scheme.
The GDA campaign marks a big departure for the industry which has,
to date, preferred to raise its concerns in private.